I found this Firing Line forum thread while traveling about the Intertubz. It dates from 2014, but it's the closest thing to a scientific test of firearm cleaning, lubrication and protection products I've seen--46 tested in all. Be sure to read all 4 pages of the thread, as DIY_guy adds more info as it progresses.
I've been a big fan of Eezox for some years now, and it does test out in the middle of the pack. I've also used Hornady One Shot for some time as a quick way to clean actions and trigger groups. However, given the results of these tests, I think when I run out of Eezox I'm going to have to try some Frog Lube.